Was there racism in ancient Greece?
Who made antiquity “white”?
How the “red” Greeks and Romans became representatives of the “white supremacy”: Reconstruction of a culture war.
Who would have thought that the study of classical antiquity would still have an impact? That it could even be classified as so dangerous that some are calling for it to be abolished? Some prominent academics at US universities argue that the culture of the ancient Greeks and Romans is the founding myth of the racist and colonialist western civilization, the “white supremacy”. Some go so far as to question the right to exist of the "Classics", as classical philology is called there. Recently Howard University in Washington, D.C. decided to close its department ("Die Presse" reported). How should, how can one understand this American culture war over antiquity?
At least as a proxy war. The ancient Greeks and Romans did not know any racism of skin color, had no concept for it. They did not see themselves as white either, but if they did, then as red. The peoples of the north, such as the Celts and Teutons, were considered white to them. As brown, for example, the Egyptians and Mauritanians. As black the Nubians, Ethiopians or Indians. These categories were seen by Greek geographers as the result of different levels of solar radiation. They were ideologically meaningless. This is also proven by the art in which people of different skin colors were portrayed as equal.
An Arab skin color racism
There are hardly any concepts of ethnic purity. The Roman Empire stands out precisely because of its multiculturalism. No matter whether Syrians, Judeans, Nubians, Egyptians or Gauls, everyone could acquire citizenship, it was not tied to ethnic origin. Equally rare was the idea that certain peoples were “naturally” inferior. An exception was Aristotle, who said that there are “slaves by nature”. This theory remained remarkably irrelevant in ancient times itself.
However, according to Greek scholars, one factor in nature could favor the development of “better” or “worse” peoples: the climate. They attributed their own high culture and democracy to a "medium", in their eyes optimal climate and sometimes speculated about the connection between climate and character traits. This Hellenistic climate determinism then also led to the first racism of skin color. However, not in Greco-Roman antiquity, but centuries later in the Arab world. From the 10th century onwards, geographers from Iraq to Persia, among them Avicenna, took up the Hellenistic climate theories - but now with clear hierarchies linked to skin colors. For them, the “whites” (Slavs, Turks, Chinese) were among the inferior peoples, like the black Africans, while the “red” or “light brown” peoples were of high quality.
For the racist readings of antiquity, of course, Arab geographers of the 10th century are as little responsible as the ancient Greeks and Romans. Who else? Perhaps the inventors of “white antiquity”? The archaeologist Johann Joachim Winckelmann, who not only shaped the image of antiquity in German classical music, is now denounced as such. Starting with white antique sculptures like the Apollo of Belvedere, he developed his ideal of culture - the “noble simplicity and quiet grandeur” of the ancient Greeks. According to the critics, he thus shaped the image of a “white” antiquity as a superior civilization.
"Since the white color is the one which sends back the most rays of light, the whiter it is, the more beautiful a body will be, the more beautiful it is": This is what Winckelmann actually wrote in his "History of Ancient Art" (1764). The fact that, despite traces of paint on ancient sculptures, he considered the painting to be an exception has nothing to do with the racist theories of the following century. Above all, it was a backlash against the late Baroque opulence of its time. For him, the ancient Greeks did not prove the superiority of their own culture, but on the contrary their plaintiveness.
- Why were the 80s so great
- Why are the Nordic countries so rich
- Christians pray for Satan
- Is BBA from VIPS good
- What is binary search
- What is cement board siding
- How are guardian spirits assigned to people
- Why is nursing mostly a woman's job?
- What started an increase in climate change
- What do you mean by good morning
- Which is soundproof drywall or plywood
- 812 Kbps is a good internet speed
- What is the DSC system
- How popular is the Mexican cuisine in China
- What are vinyl albums worth nowadays
- The geordie accent is easy to understand
- How are people born
- Does Anthony Bourdain own any restaurants
- What Indian Companies Are Recruiting Online
- Actresses masturbate
- Which is the best broadband in Gurgaon
- Corrections officers are considered law enforcement officers
- How are women in their 20s
- Should we buy all of Apple's stock now
- Do you like london
- Set goals for 2019
- How is mechanical engineering as a career
- Why don't Mongolians like Chinese?
- What do scientists think of religious people
- Can suffering improve people
- What are the most dangerous zodiac signs
- What is the cheapest SMS phone only plan
- Will Ed Boyden win a Nobel Prize
- Which religions were presidents