Plato respected Diogenes

Plato Handbook pp 19-59 | Cite as

  • Christoph Horn
  • Jörn Müller
  • Joachim Söder
  • Anna Schriefl
  • Simon Weber
  • 1Citations
  • 467 downloads

Summary

At first glance it seems paradoxical that Plato, despite his vehement criticism of the scriptures - which was also presented in writing (see Chapter VI.3) - laid down his philosophy not only in writing, but even with indisputable literary ambitions. In addition, the large number of no less than 47 work titles that have been associated with Plato's authorship is surprising. Admittedly, many of these writings were already considered to be false or at least dubious in antiquity, but in today's research a good two dozen dialogues are recognized as genuine. Allegedly, Plato himself is said to have arranged certain related writings into groups of works; At least that is what a report in Diogenes Laertios III 56 reads: “Thrasyllos claims that he [Plato] published the dialogues on the model of the tragic tetralogies, just as one entered the competition there with four dramas. [...] But the four pieces were called tetralogy. "

This is a preview of subscription content, log in to check access.

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

literature

  1. Alline, Henri 1915a: Histoire du texte de Platon. Paris [repr. 1984]. Google Scholar
  2. - 1915b: "Aristophane de Byzance et son édition critique de Platon". In: Revue des Études Anciennes 17, 85–97.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Annas, Julia 1999: Platonic Ethic Old and New. Ithaca.Google Scholar
  4. Arnim, Hans from 1896: De Platonis dialogis quaestiones chronologicae. Rostock.Google Scholar
  5. Barnes, Jonathan 1991: "The Hellenistic Platos". In: Apeiron 24, 115–128. CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Bickel, Ernst 1944a: "The Platonic corpus of the 9 tetralogies and the interpolation in the Plato text". In: Rheinisches Museum 92, 94–96.Google Scholar
  7. - 1944b: "History and Recensio of the Platon Text". In: Rheinisches Museum 92, 97–159.Google Scholar
  8. Blass, Friedrich 1874: The Attic eloquence. Section 2: Isocrates and Isaios. Leipzig.Google Scholar
  9. Brandwood, Leonard 1990: The Chronology of Plato's Dialogues. Cambridge.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. - 1992: "Stylometry and Chronology". In: Richard Kraut (ed.): The Cambridge Companion to Plato. Cambridge, 90-120. CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Brisson, Luc 2005: »Epinomis: Authenticity and Authorship «. In: Klaus Döring / Michael Erler / Stefan Schorn (eds.): Pseudoplatonica. Suttgart 2005, 9–24. Google Scholar
  12. Campbel, Lewis 1867: The Sophistes other Politicus of Plato. Oxford.Google Scholar
  13. Carlini, Antonio 1972: Studi sulla tradizione antica e medievale del Fedone. Roma.Google Scholar
  14. - 1992: »Sul papiro Flinders Petrie I 5-8 del Fedone«. In: Studi su codici e papiri filosofici: Platone, Aristotele, Ierocle. Firenze, 147–159.Google Scholar
  15. Cherniss, Harold 1945: The Riddle of the Early Academy. Berkely (German: The older academy. A historical riddle and its solution. Heidelberg 1966) .Google Scholar
  16. Chroust, Anton-Hermann 1965: “The Organization of the Corpus Platonicum in Antiquity «. In: Hermes 93, 34-46.Google Scholar
  17. Cobb, William S. 1988: “Plato's Minos«. In: Ancient Philosophy 8, 187-207. CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Cooper, John M. 1997: "Introduction". In: John M. Cooper (ed.): Plato. Complete Works. Indianapolis, ix–xxix.Google Scholar
  19. Corlett, J. Angelo 2005: Interpreting Plato's Dialogues. Las Vegas.Google Scholar
  20. Denyer, Nicholas 2001: "Introduction". In: Ders. (Ed.): Plato: Alcibiades. Cambridge, 1-29. CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Dittenberger, Wilhelm 1881: "Linguistic criteria for the chronology of the Platonic dialogues". In: Hermes 16, 321–345.Google Scholar
  22. Dixsaut, Monique 1985: Le naturel philosophe. Essai sur les dialogues de Plato. Paris.Google Scholar
  23. Döring, Klaus 2004: "Appendizes". In: Plato: Theages. Göttingen, 73–85.Google Scholar
  24. Dover, Kenneth J. 1965: "The Date of Plato's Symposium". In: Phronesis 10, 2–20. CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Erbse, Hartmut 1961: "History of the transmission of Greek classical and Hellenistic literature". In: Herbert Hunger et al. (Ed.): History of the text transmission of ancient and medieval literature. Zurich, 207–283.Google Scholar
  26. Erler, Michael 2005: "Philosophical autobiography using the example of Plato's 7th letter". In: Michael Reichel (ed.): Ancient autobiographies. Works - epochs - genres. Cologne, 75–92.Google Scholar
  27. - 2007: Plato. Outline of the history of philosophy: antiquity 2/2. Basel.Google Scholar
  28. Ferber, Rafael 2007: Why didn't Plato write the ›unwritten teaching‹? Munich [extended reprint of: The ignorance of the philosopher or why did Plato not write the ›unwritten teaching‹? St. Augustin 1991]. Google Scholar
  29. Frede, Michael 1992: "Plato's Arguments and the Dialogue Form". In: James Klagge / Nicholas Smith (eds.): Methods of Interpreting Plato and his Dialogues. Oxford, 201-219. Google Scholar
  30. Gaiser, Konrad 1963: Plato's unwritten teaching. Studies on the systematic and historical foundation of the sciences in the Platonic school. Stuttgart.Google Scholar
  31. Griswold, Charles 2002: "Preface". In: Ders. (Ed.): Platonic Readings / Platonic Writings. University Park, ix-xvii.Google Scholar
  32. Haslam, Nichael W. 1997: “E. A. Duke et al. (edd.): Platonis Opera, tomus I. Oxford 1995 «[review]. In: Bryn Mawr Classical Review 97.1.7 (no page numbers). Google Scholar
  33. Havelock, Eric A. 1986: The Muse Learns to Write. Reflections on Orality and Literacy from Antiquity to the Present. New Haven.Google Scholar
  34. Heitsch, Ernst 1997: "Appendizes". In: Plato: Phaedrus. Göttingen, 231–264.Google Scholar
  35. - 2004: Plato and the beginnings of his dialectical philosophizing. Göttingen.Google Scholar
  36. Hermann, Karl F. 1839: History and system of the Platonic philosophy. Heidelberg.Google Scholar
  37. Hoog, Ingeborg 1965: The value of the Laches- and Phaidon papyrus from Arsinoe for the Plato tradition. With a new edition of the parts of the Plato text preserved in both papyri. Diss. Hamburg.Google Scholar
  38. Hyland, Drew 2004: Questioning Platonism. Continental Interpretations of Plato. Albany.Google Scholar
  39. Irigoin, Jean 1986: "Deux traditions dissymétriques: Platon et Aristote". In: Annuaire du Collège de France (1985-86). Paris, 683-696.Google Scholar
  40. Isnardi Parente, Margherita 1997/98: Testimonia Platonica (Vol. 1 1997: Le testimonianze di Aristotele; Vol. 2 1998: Testimonianze di età ellenistica e di età imperiale). Roma.Google Scholar
  41. Jachmann, Günther 1942: The Platon text. Göttingen.Google Scholar
  42. Janell, Walther (Gualtherus) 1901: "Quaestiones Platonicae". In: Yearbooks for Classical Philology, Supplement 26, 263–336.Google Scholar
  43. Kahn, Charles 1996: Plato and the Socratic Dialogue. The Philosophical Use of a Literary Form. Cambridge.Google Scholar
  44. Klagge, James 1992: "Editor’s Prologue". In: James Klagge / Nicholas Smith (eds.): Methods of Interpreting Plato and his Dialogues. Oxford.Google Scholar
  45. Klein, Jacob 1965: A Commentary on Plato's Meno. Chapel Hill.Google Scholar
  46. Krämer, Hans 1959: Aretê with Plato and Aristotle. On the nature and history of the Platonic ontology. Heidelberg.Google Scholar
  47. - 1982: Platone e i fondamenti della metafisica. Saggio sulla teoria dei principi e sulle dottrine non steps di Platone con una raccolta dei documenti fondamentali. Milano (Plato and the Foundations of Metaphysics. New York 1990). Google Scholar
  48. - 1996: »Plato's unwritten teaching«. In: Theo Kobusch / Burkhard Mojsisch (eds.): Platon. His dialogues from the perspective of new research. Darmstadt, 249–275.Google Scholar
  49. Kristeller, Paul O. 1978: "The first printed Edition of Plato's Works and the Date of its Publication (1484)". In: Erna Hilfstein et al. (Ed.): Science and History. Studies in Honor of E. Rosen. Wroclaw, 25–35.Google Scholar
  50. Ledger, Gerald R. 1989: Re-Counting Plato. A computer analysis of Plato's style. Oxford.Google Scholar
  51. Manuwald, Bernd 2005: »On the pseudoplatonic character of the Minos. Observations on the structure of dialogue and argumentation «. In: Klaus Döring / Michael Erler / Stefan Schorn (eds.): Pseudoplatonica. Stuttgart 2005, 135–154.Google Scholar
  52. Müller, Carl W. 1975: The short dialogues of the Appendix Platonica. Philological contributions to post-Platonic Socratics. Munich.Google Scholar
  53. Nails, Debra 1993: "Problems with Vlastos’s Platonic Developmentalism". In: Ancient Philosophy 13, 273-291. CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  54. - 1995: Agora, Academy, and the Conduct of Philosophy. Dordrecht.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  55. - 2002: The People of Plato: A Prosopography of Plato and Other Socratics. Indianapolis.Google Scholar
  56. - / Thesleff, Holger 2003: "Early Academic Editing". In: Sanuel Scolnicov / Luc Brisson (eds.): Plato’s Laws. From theory into practice. Proceedings of the VI Symposium Platonicum. St. Augustin, 14–29.Google Scholar
  57. Pasquali, Giorgio 1952: Storia della tradizione e critica del testo. 2., ext. Edition [11934]. Firenze.Google Scholar
  58. Penner, Terry 1992: "Socrates and the Early Dialogues". In: Richard Kraut (ed.): The Cambridge Companion to Plato. Cambridge, 121-169. CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Pesce, Domenico 1990: Il Platone di Tubinga, e due studi sullo Stoicismo. Brescia.Google Scholar
  60. Philip, James A. 1970: "The Platonic Corpus". In: Phoenix 24, 296-308. CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  61. Pradeau, Jean-François 1999: "Appendice". In: Plato: Alcibiade. Paris, 219–220.Google Scholar
  62. Press, Gerald A. 1998: "The State of the Question in the Study of Plato". In: Nicholas Smith (ed.): Plato. Critical Assessments. Vol. 1. London, 309-332.Google Scholar
  63. Reale, Giovanni 1991: Per una nuova interpretazione di Platone. Rilettura della metafisica dei grandi dialoghi alla luce delle ›Dottrine non scritte‹. Milano (German: On a new interpretation of Plato. Paderborn 1993). Google Scholar
  64. Richard, Marie-Dominique 1986: L'enseignement oral de Platon. Paris.Google Scholar
  65. - 1993: »The question de la genèse du corpus platonicien au début du XIXe siècle «. In: Michel Tardieu (ed.): La formation des canons scripturaires. Paris, 7-46.Google Scholar
  66. Ritter, Constantin 1888: Investigations on Plato. The authenticity and chronology of the Platonic writings. Stuttgart.Google Scholar
  67. Rowe, Christopher 1992: “La data relativa del Fedro«. In: Livio Rossetti (ed.): Understanding the Phaedrus. Proceedings of the II Symposium Platonicum. St. Augustin, 31–39.Google Scholar
  68. - 2005: “What might we learn from the Clitophone about the Nature of the Academy? «In: Klaus Döring / Michael Erler / Stefan Schorn (eds.): Pseudoplatonica. Suttgart 2005, 213–224.Google Scholar
  69. - 2006: »The symposium as a Socratic Dialogue «. In: James Lesher / Debra Nails / Frisbee Sheffield (eds.): Plato’s symposium. Issues in interpretation at reception. Cambridge, Mass., 9-22. Google Scholar
  70. Sayre, Kenneth M. 1983: Plato's Late Ontology. A Riddle Resolved. Princeton.Google Scholar
  71. Schanz, Martin 1886: "On the development of the platonic style". In: Hermes 21, 439–459.Google Scholar
  72. Schefer, Christina 2001: Plato's untold experience. Another approach to Plato. Basel.Google Scholar
  73. Schironi, Francesca 2005: »Plato at Alexandria. Aristophanes, Aristarchus, and the 'Philological Tradition' of a Philosopher '. In: Classical Quarterly 55, 423-434.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  74. Schleiermacher, Friedrich 1804: "Introduction". In: Plato's works by Friedrich Schleiermacher. First Part First Volume [31855]. Berlin [repr. in: Konrad Gaiser (ed.): The picture of Plato. Ten contributions to understanding Plato. Hildesheim 1969, 1-32]. Google Scholar
  75. Schöpsdau, Klaus 1994: "Introduction". In: Plato: Nomoi (Laws). Book I – III. Göttingen, 91–145.Google Scholar
  76. Sijpesteijn, Pieter J. 1964: "The Plato Papyri". In: Aegyptus 44, 26–33.Google Scholar
  77. Solmsen, Friedrich 1981: "The Academic and the Alexandrian Editions of Plato's Works". In: Illinois Classical Studies 6, 102–111.Google Scholar
  78. Szlezák, Thomas A. 1985: Plato and the written form of philosophy. Interpretations on the early and middle dialogues. Berlin.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  79. Tarán, Leonardo 1975: Academica: Plato, Philip of Opus, and the Pseudo-Platonic Epinomis. Philadelphia.Google Scholar
  80. Tarrant, Harold 1983: Middle Platonism and the Seventh Epistle«. In: Phronesis 28, 75-103.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  81. - 1993: Thrasyllan Platonism. Ithaca.Google Scholar
  82. Thesleff, Holger 1982: Studies in Platonic Chronology. Helsinki.Google Scholar
  83. - 1989: "Platonic Chronology". In: Phronesis 34, 1–26. CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  84. Thiel, Detlef 1993: Plato's Hypomnemata. The Genesis of Platonism from the Memory of Scripture. Freiburg / Munich.Google Scholar
  85. Tigerstedt, Eugène N. 1977: Interpreting Plato. Uppsala.Google Scholar
  86. Usener, Hermann 1892: "Our Platon Text". In: News from the Royal Society of Sciences and the Georg-August University of Göttingen, Philological-Historical Class, 25–50; 181–215 [reprint. in: Hermann Usener: Kleine Schriften 3. Leipzig 1914, 104–162] .Google Scholar
  87. Vlastos, Gregory 1991: Socrates. Ironist and Moral Philosopher. Cambridge.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  88. - 1994: Socratic Studies. Cambridge.Google Scholar
  89. Wilamowitz-Moellendorff, Ulrich from 1919: Plato. 2 vols [21920]. Berlin.Google Scholar
  90. Wilson, Nigel G. 1962: "A List of Plato Manuscripts". In: Scriptorium 16, 386–395.Google Scholar
  91. Young, Charles M. 1994: "Plato and Computer Dating". In: Oxford Studies in Ancient Philosophy 12, 227–250.Google Scholar
  92. Zadro, Attilio 1996: »Sulle edizioni del›Corpus Platonicum‹Da Bekker alla nuova Oxoniense«. In: Patavium 4, 105-28. Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer-Verlag GmbH Germany 2009

Authors and Affiliations

  • Christoph Horn
  • Jörn Müller
  • Joachim Söder
  • Anna Schriefl
  • Simon Weber
  1. 1. Institute for Philosophy, University of Bonn, Germany
  2. 2. Institute for Philosophy, University of Würzburg, Germany
  3. 3. Aachen Catholic University of Applied Sciences, Germany